By John Minihan, former Senator and retired Captain in the Irish Defence Forces. John was Chair of the 2015 White Paper on Defence Ministerial Advisory Group and a member of the Commission on the Defence Forces.
Considering the deteriorating geopolitical environment in Europe, Ireland’s longstanding position on defence and neutrality is facing new challenges that require a more proactive approach. The acceptance of the recommendations of the Commission on the Defence Forces report 2022 marks a significant step towards reshaping our defence policy. As the Government moves into the detailed implementation phase, it is essential to address the implications of these changes and the evolving concept of neutrality. The July 2024 Defence Policy Review's emphasis on enhancing Ireland's defence capabilities presents a significant opportunity for defence chiefs to drive the necessary change to meet these challenges.
The Commission on the Defence Forces (CODF) very extensive mandate was to examine and make recommendations on the structures, staffing and capabilities of the Defence Forces. The Commission’s recommendations, accepted by Government, put forward proposals for transformative change in Defence Force structures, culture and people management. The changes to the command structure and governance of the Defence Forces is only relevant when considered in the context of the overall structural changes as recommended. Historically, defence organisations, like many large institutions, often face challenges in adapting to change due to established traditions, bureaucratic inertia, and resistance from within. Defence and security reasoning has to be adaptable and not be constrained by historic, doctrinal thinking.
However, reform is not without its challenges. Irish defence policy operates within the framework of neutrality, as interpreted by the government of the day, aiming to uphold national sovereignty and contribute to regional stability in ways that reflect a commitment to peace, independence, and international cooperation. This version of neutrality can often appear ambiguous due to the absence of a clear, formal definition enshrined in law or the constitution. More recently, the Government’s Consultative Forum on International Security Policy highlighted the divergence of opinion and the many interpretations of Irish neutrality.
The unpredictable nature of security threats, such as cyber warfare, terrorism, and regional conflicts, makes it increasingly important for countries to have a clear and cohesive stance on neutrality. A precisely defined neutrality policy can serve as a guiding principle for decision-makers, helping to ensure consistency and coherence in international engagements while preserving national sovereignty. This clarity could also greatly benefit the Defence Forces by allowing meaningful contribution to peacekeeping, environmental disasters and humanitarian taskforces. Moreover, proposals to reform the so-called ‘Triple Lock’ mechanism are necessary in defining Irish defence and foreign policy.
A window of opportunity
The newly released Defence Policy Review (DPR) identifies several priorities in response to current security challenges. Nevertheless, the challenge of deliverability in an efficient time frame remains a concern. There is a window of opportunity to ensure that the Defence Forces are organised on the principle of jointness, reflective of the defence of an island nation. It is both relevant and appropriate that the allocation of funding in terms of land, sea and air is set out in accordance with the stated CODF so-called ‘levels of ambition’.
Whilst Ireland actively supports the EU's Common Security and Defence Policy (CSDP), the country remains an outlier given the stated position on neutrality. Becoming a member of NATO is an unlikely scenario but the building of alliances and partnerships with regard to national defence with like-minded nations is a distinct possibility that the Defence Forces should be prepared for. There is a need to enhance interoperability via international exercises, and this can be addressed through Defence Forces participation (across all domains) in the Joint Expeditionary Force (JEF) concept.
From an agreed European defence perspective, integrating and coordinating air defence capabilities across Europe is a crucial step toward strengthening collective security. By pooling resources, sharing intelligence, and improving interoperability among national air defence systems, EU Member States can respond more effectively to emerging threats. This collaborative approach not only optimises defence capabilities but also distributes the burden of air defence more equitably among participating European nations.
When it comes to European defence, Ireland’s strategic location in the North Atlantic, technical expertise in areas like cybersecurity and surveillance, and diplomatic status as a country without imperial baggage can enable us to act as an honest broker, facilitating cooperation and fostering diplomatic relations. The country should be proactive in joining European initiatives because participation in a collaborative air defence system would be a strong display of solidarity with European neighbours, demonstrating a commitment to mutual security and stability.
Moreover, such involvement could enhance Ireland’s own air defence capacity exponentially by leveraging shared technologies, accessing a broader pool of resources, and benefiting from joint training and exercises. Participation in such projects can also foster closer ties with neighbours, reinforcing Ireland’s role in contributing to a secure and resilient Europe.
In addition, the important issue regarding the monitoring and protection of critical undersea infrastructure, which includes pipelines, communication cables, and energy transmission lines is a matter of concern for Government. Given the EU’s extensive maritime borders and the concentration of much infrastructure around Ireland, there is a disproportionate responsibility placed on Ireland to ensure the security and protection of these assets. The promotion of collaboration between Member States, sharing intelligence, best practices, and technologies to detect and respond to threats effectively should be central to national defence strategy.
Prioritising Ireland’s next steps
There are six areas which should be prioritised in the near future. First, Ireland's significant maritime and airspace responsibilities, including overseeing 16 percent of the EU’s territorial waters and 75 percent of the transatlantic undersea cables, underscore the need for robust defence and surveillance mechanisms. The country’s unique geographical position presents both a challenge and an opportunity to strengthen defence capabilities in these critical areas. Second, Ireland's strategic location and expertise in cybersecurity and surveillance can significantly contribute to European air defence initiatives. Participating in collaborative air defence efforts would enhance Ireland’s defence capabilities, provide access to shared technologies and resources, and strengthen ties with European neighbours. It would also align with Ireland’s stance on mutual security and stability in the nation’s regional environment.
Third, the Army needs to be appropriately equipped to ensure it is capable of fulfilling its diverse roles in defence, civil support, international peacekeeping, and humanitarian assistance, meaning that strategic modernisation efforts should focus on key areas. The restructuring of the Army should be prioritised to ensure efficient and appropriate capability development. Fourth, given Ireland’s disproportionate responsibility for safeguarding critical undersea infrastructure, collaboration with EU Member States is crucial. Sharing intelligence, best practices, and technologies should enhance collective defence strategies to protect vital assets.
Fifth, Ireland's policy of neutrality is perceived as ambiguous due to the lack of a formal, legal definition. Clearly defining neutrality could assist decision making, maintain national sovereignty and ensure consistency in international obligations. And lastly, the Defence Forces face an entrenched cultural mindset that values tradition and hierarchy, often resistant to change. Defence leadership must embrace a transformative approach that prioritises innovation, adaptability, and modernisation. This cultural shift is essential for the Defence Forces to remain relevant and effective in a rapidly changing, unpredictable global security climate.
To conclude, in order to navigate these challenges and seize the opportunities as presented in the DPR, the Defence Forces must adopt a strategic, unified, and forward-thinking approach. By fostering collaboration across services, engaging in European defence initiatives, and clarifying the stance on neutrality, Ireland can enhance its defence position while maintaining core values of peace, sovereignty, and international cooperation. This transformation will require not only policy changes but also a deep cultural shift within the Defence Forces to support a modern and responsive defence strategy. It should be recognised that the burdens of external border management, maritime, and air security, which are borne, in the main, by Ireland due to its strategic location on the western front of Europe, are shared responsibilities of the EU. As such, these critical tasks require collective investment from the EU to ensure that Ireland can effectively fulfil its role in safeguarding the Union's strategic interests.
John Minihan is a former Senator and retired Army Officer. As a member of the Progressive Democrats, he was part of the negotiating team for the 2002 Programme for Government and Chair of the Parliamentary Party. He contributes as an EU Expert-Evaluator and Consensus Meeting Rapporteur for the ‘Science with and for Society Calls’ and an EU Ethics-Expert Horizon Europe Ethics appraisal scheme. He was Chair of the 2015 White Paper Ministerial Advisory Group and a member of the Commission on the Defence Forces.

